Transcript 0:00 [instrumental music] Conversations with Curators brings a collection of audio stories that explore the soul of Switzerland as an art capital. 0:10 In this series, we focus on in-depth interviews with museum curators across the country. 0:17 Hear first-hand about their institutions, the histories behind their collections, and the unique perspectives they bring to preserving Swiss culture. 0:28 From intimate conversations about their curatorial choices to behind-the-scenes insights into exhibitions, every episode captures the voices shaping Switzerland's cultural landscape. 0:42 Discover Switzerland through the eyes of those who safeguard its heritage one interview at a time. This is Conversations with Curators. 0:53 Monsieur Nicolas Darrot, thank you for speaking to us and being on Conversation with Curators. You began your training at the École de l'Architecture in Grenoble and then Beaux-Arts in Paris. 1:07 Talk about your background and transition from static buildings towards moving arts. Oh. [laughs] There's much to do with that shift. I shifted from 1:22 visual arts to kinetic arts during my studies at the fine arts school in Paris, involved with a group of other students. 1:31 Yes, there wasn't, there wasn't exactly a course of kinetic arts, but we had this workshop with, uh, tools and a lot of facilities to weld iron, build some small iron sculptures. 1:46 And it was possible to, to follow the way of mechanical arts if we were interested in that. So I started small with very simple machines and came to learn electronics later on. But it took years [laughs]. 2:02 But the first machines were very simple. It took years to change the perception from one kind of arts to another. What took time? The... I'm an old person [laughs] 2:17 , so I was ch- I did my studies before internet, before it was like the prehistorical world. Mm-hmm. 2:28 So I had to, yes, and it took a lot, a lot of time to find information and to develop some skills in some- the kind of technical skills I was looking for. 2:39 Like, just to control movements, to do some simple automations, and all the, the programming skills that go around with the idea of, of developing a sound, an audio automat, which was my project. 2:54 Took me years because there wasn't any student, any teacher for that part in my art school, and the artists working on that direction in Paris were very few. 3:11 But I had a chance to meet a couple of, well, of them that did show me some simple things and helped me to, to evolve in that way. You were born in the port city of Le Havre. Yes [laughs]. 3:27 Did the industrial, mechanical atmosphere, the maritime atmosphere- Mm-hmm … have an impact on the choice- [laughs] … of you being an artist? I just, I just, yeah, I just left, I was, like, 14 months [laughs]. Aha. 3:44 It was not such an influence. But I grew up in the Alps, I grew up in the mountains, which, yes, was very... It's more my background. And as mountains have much to do with space and, uh, volumes and, uh, sculpture. 3:57 Right. So I think it, it played, it, yeah, it did something to, to the choice I made to be an artist. Mm-hmm. 4:08 The exhibition is named after a type of artificial intelligence that deals with gradations rather than ones and zeros, like you say. Yeah. 4:19 Why did you want to translate this mathematical concept to imprecision and mood swings? Uh, well, the, 4:32 the work on the fuzzy logic theory came in the context of how do human or machine learn? 4:40 And at the same time that I had my first child and had the joy of seeing him grow and learn things like how to talk, how to walk, and I share these very precious moments with him. 4:54 I kept an eye on what was going on in robotics. And it was the early times of the internet and, uh, robotic research laboratories, especially in Japan, 5:09 starting to publish very short videos of what they were able to achieve in terms of programming and how to program machines to learn. And the fuzzy logic concept was a 5:24 kind of ground to this evolution of programming. It was the time of what they used to call the neural network programming. And what fascinated me in these videos that they did show very simple mechanics 5:42 that did try to achieve something, like go in one direction, but they had to learn how to achieve this goal by themself. 5:56 And the videos did show a series of failed tempta- tentative to achieve the goal until they succeed. But the success was always in the end. And I don't know why, but I had the idea to reproduce it 6:11 in my studio and to do the same kind of mechanics and see what, what goes on. And what went on was failure and failure. 6:21 And it turned out that it was more interesting to me to, to build a narration around failure than around success because it was more funny, it was more engaging for the public, it was more, more interesting. 6:37 And it made me think about why would we learn to talk? Why would we learn to walk? Is it a goal that we have to touch to, to accomplish ourself as human beings? 6:51 Or is it something that is a part of us and has more to do with, uh, our natural evolution and the way we are together and, and that's about the time when the fuzzy logic concept detached itself from the, its actual mathematical signification to shift into a kind of bunch of nonsense situations that I could play with involving machines and puppets and characters trying to figure out the sense of the situations that they are in. 7:26 So it's a very long answer, but [laughs] But it is the perfect answer to- Mm... a, a question which I was not sure about asking because I didn't know if it made sense. But- Mm-hmm... 7:38 after listening to your answer, it does. So you're trying to figure out if it is something innate, primal in our creation 7:49 or is it something we learn from around our society and gradually want to adapt, experience, understand? Is it something internal that is telling us to speak, touch, write, walk like you mentioned about your child? 8:06 Or is it something that we are told to do from the outside that you should study and- This is deep. [laughs] We are now entering the very- Yes, we are now [laughs]... philosophical zone of the interview. 8:19 [laughs] We are now entering to the second episode of the podcast but [laughs] Well, we are now [laughs] It's a deep question. Yeah. 8:26 There is this, I hear at the Tang Museum now a fantastic exhibition of Carl Cheng called Nature Never Exists. And in my opinion, but it's only my opinion [laughs] 8:41 , when we grow up, when we learn things, we're just taking part into what is our global condition as human beings, but not separated from nature in its global way of developing its own language, challenging gravity. 9:00 All the skills that human beings can achieve when they grow up. They do it the same way as a plant grows up. They just do it because it's, it's... They are the part of the, they are... How do you, how would you say that? 9:18 They are kind of formed in, in the fabric of nature. So that's my opinion. Yeah. And this is the main difference between, between our condition and the machine, the way they behave. 9:35 Because machines are always, even when they are very complex, they are always a bunch, group of parts of different parts put together and you can replace the parts, but that's not the way we are. 9:50 We are not built like machines. You can't separate a part of us and just replace. And the other thing that machine don't have and that we have, it's we have the gift to have a birth and a death. 10:08 So we have a condition, so that's what makes the game interesting. [laughs] I love the fact that you say, call it a condition. 10:20 Birth and death, you call it that we have this condition that we die. Yeah. It's the, it's the same rule for- That's the whole deal [laughs] Yeah. That's the deal. The same rule for all of us. Yeah. 10:32 That's not the deal with the machine. No. Yeah. But we like to think that maybe it's not gonna happen. I know. That's something- Yeah... 10:40 that we don't like to think about so much, but it determines a lot of things in what we do, so. It determines how we live. Yeah, sure. Yeah. It's the major, the major information. I found the space 10:56 where your exhibit is very ironical in terms of trying to talk about, especially being in this museum where size matters in terms of large, massive machines in play, 11:14 and a small window is dedicated, which is not reflective of the value of your art. I understand that. But talk about the space- [laughs]... the choice, the size of your exhibit. 11:27 Sometimes it's better to do small things good than very big things and you just can't deal with it. That's one thing. 11:36 The other thing is that this place in the museum is the former telephone c- cabin, which gives him strange status. There used to be something there. 11:48 There used to be a place here where you could call with this kind of machine that now almost everyone has forgot- forgotten. And it's, so it's ghosty place in the museum. So I think it was interesting to, to 12:07 design something for this place. And by the way, it's a place that is used for presentation or half, half program pieces and has a special status in the museum that is, I think, quite interesting 12:23 It's often good to be just aside the big screen, so it's a plan that I like. And it was the m- the, it give me the opportunity to think about a kind of scenario 12:38 to engage the public to go downstairs, and to get to know that there is something more to see in the museum. So that's why we thought about with the director of the museum this system of bonus cards. 12:54 So when you come here in the Tinguely Museum, you, you buy your ticket, and they will give you another card that lets you trigger the theater downstairs. So this is, uh, something that you can keep, 13:08 and playing cards are somehow relating to magic. That's... They are very charged objects. They have very symbolic pictograms on it, and the way you organize them, it... 13:25 They make figures and maybe you are able to predict the future with it, or you are going to know the hidden personality of a person and they have a special status. 13:38 So I like the idea to, to bring some, some literacy in the project. So that's why we chose this design made by Salvador Dali, who has a very strong connection with dreams and fantasy. 13:53 It was a way to connect the project with some external influences. Yes, uh, some child novels, some, well, texts about the puppets and some small references like that. So. 14:06 You also mentioned the card which is used to activate the exhibit is a reminiscent of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory- Yeah... and the golden ticket. [laughs] Yes. Yes. In the, 14:23 in the video game culture, they have this thing that they call the Easter egg. It's a hidden reward inside the game. So I liked this idea that, okay, there is the overall scenario. 14:37 You have your ticket, you can trigger the machine, but somehow you may have a special ticket. These are five acts, and they would be released one after another. 14:49 Would they replace the same telephone booth, or would they be next to each other? How have you planned it, or is it a surprise? 14:56 [laughs] The telephone place was a bit too small for my, my mechanical bases, so I had to build a small extension of the space, which pretty much looks like a classical puppet theater 15:14 with a red curtain that opens itself and you see the character, the human character on display. And this is the part that I'm going to change. So the theater will stay the, at, uh, the same place, 15:29 and I will just come and, and change the character each time. Talk about the character that has been unveiled today. [laughs] So the first of all of them is called Nanashi Chan, 15:44 which is the title of a song of Japanese punk band called Akai Koorage. And, uh, what can I say? They are very intense. [laughs] And the singer, in particular, is a very, 16:03 is amazing, has this amazing way of singing with a witch voice. 16:08 I don't know how to describe it, but it's so different that the way she looks and the way she talks in the normal life, it's just as if she had this personality that switches on at the time she goes on stage. 16:24 So I found it very... It was a match with, with the things I'm trying to do with my mechanical puppets. I sent him the, sent them the video of the puppet, but didn't get any answer yet. 16:40 So Jean Tinguely, the museum also where we are sitting, he was a pioneer in satirizing technological overproduction. He has often made machines which are nonsensical, which 16:54 use so many actions and activities, and end up doing nothing in the end. Do you think your work is a continuation of his legacy in some way, or a departure from it by 17:11 your art doing something and achieving something? I can put out my interpretation, but it is your interview, so- [laughs]... what do you think? [laughs] Yes. 17:25 What Tinguely did a lot and what I think I'm doing as well is reuse, reuse components that were not genuinely designed or produced for the use that we invent, and it's, it's the core of the critical part of Jean Tinguely's work. 17:43 So he, it, it was his way to criticize the excess of production, of the industrial society, of the consummation. But at the same time, he, 18:02 he did pay a lot of attention to get people together to build communities with o- other artists. He was very generous, and he invited a lot of fellow artists to take part in his projects, 18:19 and he was also a very funny guy. So very generous and funny, and there is a lot of humor in his works. And I like that too. 18:30 But his humor was involving, for instance, stepping outside the gallery and organizing the show outside in the street. So he had a relationship to folk art in the sense of being popular. 18:43 So going toward the people and trying to meet them and trying to speak to everyone, and this is something that I think is very valuable. Yes, it's, it's a very important legacy to me. Yeah. 18:58 In a way, making art accessible and making it everywhere around you instead of making it something about which is very remote and inaccessible. 19:10 [clears throat] Y- yes, and most of all, yeah, I think it's important to speak to everyone, not leave too much door closed. 19:18 Of course, when you do something, you can think about different levels of readability, but it's important that everyone finds a door to step in and come back with something. And I think Tinguely did that very well, so. 19:35 This brings me to my last question of art and interaction. The fact that visitors have to do something to activate the art in a way- Mm-hmm... is a very conscious choice it appears to me. Mm-hmm. 19:51 It could have also gone on a loop, and people could have stood there, seen it, and moved on. Mm-hmm. Why did you make this choice of making visitors engage with what is happening with your art? 20:06 You're saying the word to engage. It's not the same because [machine whirring] the gesture of taking your ticket out of your pocket and put- putting it, it's even it's very small. It's a kind of gift, and 20:23 you're going to wait for something in return. So there is an exchange, and I think it's very different from being triggered by a PIR sensor and something goes on, and you didn't ask for anything. 20:38 And here you put, and in the former telephone cabs, you had to put some coins. 20:45 And I remember being in Africa a long time ago and trying to call my parents, telephone cabs, and I had a hand of coins, but it was like the biggest coins. It was 10 francs, which is, now should be around €1. 21:03 And the cabin was swallowing my -- She was swallowing my coins like a monster just for me to say five words to my parents, and that was it. It was... And 21:17 I was thinking about that before the opening because this cabin was like a very strange tunnel in the earth between Africa and, and my home swallowing money. 21:29 And, yeah, the way you trigger a machine is important because it has some, some symbolic. Yeah, there is the symbolic in it is important to me. 21:37 But it's the first time that we design or that I chose to design this system of coins. So we'll see what, what happens. Let's see how many tickets the machine swallows. [laughs] That's it. Yeah. Mr. 21:51 Nicolas, thank you so much for being on Conversation with Curators. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. 21:56 After the break, join us for a conversation between Nicolas Darrot and Andres Bardy, the vice director of Museum Tinguely, Basel. [upbeat music] Good evening. 22:11 We want to start with Heinrich von Kleist. 22:15 Nicolas, you told me that Kleist's text on the marionette theater or on the puppet theater, depends on the translation, was important and influential for you and that it was, in a way, the intellectual starting point for your works, which you have summarized under the title of Fuzzy Logic. 22:37 As I suppose that many of you, of our guests today may not have this text in mind as I didn't myself, of course, so let me give you a very short sum up of it. 22:53 It's a short text, uh, just some ei- six to eight pages, which first appeared 1810 in four parts in the Berliner Abendblatt. 23:05 In his essay, Heinrich von Kleist explores how human consciousness destroys natural grace. A narrator converses with a dancer, Herr P, who argues that lifeless marionettes are vastly more graceful than human beings. 23:23 Because we suffer from self-consciousness and affection, our natural ph- physical flow is disrupted. Marionettes, guided entirely by the laws of gravity and completely free of ego, move with effortless perfection. 23:41 Herr P illustrates his point with two stories. 23:44 First, a beautiful adolescent boy permanently loses his natural elegance the moment he notices his reflection in a mirror and self-consciously tries to recreate a pose. 24:00 Second, a captive bear effortlessly parries every thrust of an expert fencer because the animal relies on pure instinct, unburdened by o- human overthinking. 24:16 Ultimately, Kleist uses this as a philosophical and actually allegory for the fail of man. Gaining self-awareness caused humanity its original innocence 24:29 Since we cannot regress and unlearn our consciousness, Health Say concludes we must press forward. 24:36 To regain true godlike grace, humanity must pass completely through the infinite to reach a state of absolute knowledge, essentially eating from the tree of knowledge a second time. Nicolas, 24:54 maybe you tell us a little bit about Kleist and your punk rock singing [laughs] machine charm- [laughs]... and what they have in common. [laughs] I just would like to thank as well 25:11 Roland for his wonderful invitation and of course Andres and all the team of the museum that supported the project. It's very new for me to develop a project in the long timescale 25:27 with a unique piece at the same place, so it somehow has to do with a narrative form. And that's why we imagine this system of barcode tickets which came for me from the story of the 25:44 Roald Dahl novel called Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, where there is a possibility that you somehow get the golden ticket and trigger a secret sequence in the automat theater. So that was the idea. 26:00 And to stay in the childish universe we borrowed for the ticket design, the design of logo that Salvador Dali did for the Chupa Chups candies. 26:13 So it was two, two way to, to maybe connect the project to some childhood imaginary. Or how would you say that? 26:23 So to watching them growing up and learning how to talk, how to walk, well, all the things that children do. I tried to, to design some s- scenes to represent how machine come to learn things. 26:41 So it came out in first theatrical forms involving a small puppet and a piece of machinery trying to perform something like... The first one was a mechanical, a vocal apparatus trying to say some words. 26:58 And another one was a small caterpillar, a mechanical caterpillar trying to learn how to, how to go from a point A to a point B. 27:08 And it was all about how do machine learn and why would they learn to do something in comparing them to the way that human being can evolve and learn new skills. 27:21 And that's how I came to discover this fuzzy logic concept, which is a mathematical concept of how to program machine and help them to adapt to a fuzzy world. And 27:36 it, it came together with this Kleist short text that mainly talks about how objects come to dance. If you consider that dance is a way to agree and compose with gravity. And, uh, it... 27:53 I found that it was a very interesting basis to connect together sculpture questions with, with something that came out to be more like performance work. 28:06 The idea of fuzzy logic, which is a, uh, is the question of a computer, for example, which is a computer basically can only say yes or no or zero and one. And has no gray between the white and the black. 28:23 But it's very important if you wants to have a computer which gets closer to human thinking that you... That he can say gray or he can say perhaps. But it's all against this binary thinking. 28:41 Of course, the computer does not think as we know, but of this binary concept of a computer. And so it's the concept of fuzzy logic. 28:50 It's opening up this very strict world of our computers and that's how I think it's, it's exactly the, the opposite of what Kleist describes in, in... 29:03 When he says that the mechanical dancer is much better than a human dancer because it's, it's just geared by mechanical means and not by thinking or by, by feelings or by wanting to be something which it, it's not. 29:21 And... Yes. 29:24 What is, what is not said in the text that is that Kleist the dancer identifies himself with the small-scaled objects, and it has a, a kind of disinhibition effects on him 29:42 that helps him to engage with the emotions that he can project on the small scale characters. 29:50 And this is exactly the experience that I had the first time I was in situation of programming this new kind of puppets because following this idea of fuzzy logic programming, I tried to design some programming platforms that did allow me to stop programming machines using code line, code lines, 30:12 and to program them using a physical interface instead. 30:18 And I had the, this first situation to, to be in front of a small character that I designed and to make it move and to see it speak With my voice at the same time in synchronization to me. 30:34 And it, it was a kind of a very strange encounter and very disinhibiting for me, and very new because I'm not a performer artist. 30:45 But it turned out that this part of the work involved quite a long time of devoted to organizing this small performance time, which is somehow the core of the work if you, if you don't consider all the technique around the work. 31:03 And th- this is the main relationship with this text of Kleist. The idea of putting a live performance inside an object that is going to play over and over, like we can see in the sequence outside. Yeah. 31:16 What, what seems to me very interesting is that if it's not robots, it's, uh, it's not or may... It's basically, it's a, 31:26 it's a figure which is an acting with mechanical means and then so on, but it's in no way what we would think about as being a robot. A robot with where every movement is, is directed 31:43 entirely by the machine. Your figures, your puppets act completely differently. They... There's a lot of chance in this, in, in these movements. Yes. 31:58 There, there's a lot of thing happening in the way that gravity is transmitted via the small, uh, strings, 32:07 which can often be loose or, or tense in a dyssymmetrical way, and it makes the puppet move in a very eerie way, which I... Something I like very much because it make it overact in a way. 32:25 And I think it creates a situation where this character look very disinhibited. So this is, this is something that I'm looking for when I work on these, these puppets. 32:35 You, you said in discussion we had that one essential quality of mankind is falling and failing. That people, they, they get ill, they break a leg, whatever. 32:48 Whereas in a machine definitely does not have the right to, to fail. 32:54 A machine has to function, to work properly, and this is something which is probably, uh, also very important in, in when I look at the machine. This is not a machine which has not the right to get ill. 33:14 He has said I'm trying to design machines, and I shouldn't say that to the maintenance team, but- They're already laughing out there. [laughs] I think something gets more interesting with the... 33:26 when these kind of machines are fragile. So when people can feel that somehow they are on the point, they are close to the point where they are going to break, 33:37 it reinforces the engagement of the public toward the objects. And it make, in a way, these puppets feel more, more like us in the sense of the fragility of the human condition. 33:51 The, this possibility of, of failing, of doing things wrong is very human. So it's, it's a trick for me to, to engage people in a way that they can project themselves in these kind of objects. 34:07 Because the time and the possibility of engagement for the public in the context of the show is very short, so you have to, you have to create a situation that, 34:20 that engage people, that make them think, "How does it work?" Or, "It won't work that long because it's too fragile." Or show something, uh, hysterical to create like a, a funny situation. 34:35 And just, yes, it's, it's my way to, to, to attract the public with these objects. Yeah. I, I also think that- Mm... I as a viewer, I develop a kind of a emotional connection to this puppet. 34:48 It's not that I just see something happening, then it's over. And so I, I feel with it. It's, it's a immediate connection which, which is goes far over to just watching. 35:05 But you said also fragility. That's... This is, I think, a very important word in, in, in your work as well. Yes. It's fragility. 35:15 And for this series, or this specific Frazz logic series, there is a kind of, there is a casting. That means I look for voices or I look for 35:26 mainly music bands or m- music composers or eerie voices that I can hear, 35:34 like in the street or in the people I, I can meet that could be, that could fit th- this kind of eerie format and a small scale character. Because the puppets move in a certain way because they are small. 35:50 And I think that the voice and the sound that surrounds them, that comes with the character is here to, to match this way of being. So this is, 36:00 this has come to form a kind of group of characters that, that I can reuse from time to time and that can travel from a show to the other, from a region of the world from to the other. 36:14 For instance, the last one that will be presented next year is a kind of snowman living in the Japanese mountains. And it's a yokai that I was told about when I happened to work on a project over there, 36:29 and he became the leader of a, of a puppet band that plays in a permanent installation over there in Japan. 36:37 And I reused him here back in France in the idea of, of building an, some kind of connection between the French harps and the Japanese harps while they're using the same character. 36:51 And he got the same voice here than there, and he plays the same instruments. Yeah, Japan, uh, seems to be, anyway, very important also for this work which we are showing today, Nanashi Chan. There, 37:07 there is the song or the songs. There are five different songs which his puppet is singing and dancing to. They all come from a Japanese band, Kai Kurane. Correct spelled? Yes. Pronounced? And it's a Japanese... 37:24 But did you ever see them live? No, unfortunately, we did not meet. But it was- Not all right... why Google them and have a look at their videos this way. And so you've been in 2022 in, in Japan- Yes... 37:40 for the Setouchi Triennale, and this seems to have been, made a big impression to you or a big influence. Yes, we are very compatible, so [laughs]... 37:54 There, I found their relationships with objects that I feel very comfortable with, yes. I don't know what to say. It's, it, it's, it's... 38:04 You don't have so often in the world the occasion to experience the complete nonsense, and it fits very much with the, this part of the work, the Fudzilogik project. Having the opportunity to 38:18 go on with this work over there was very... 38:20 It was a chance, and I met people who were there who were very supportive and who, who had the same mindset about how to, how to do a mechanical project that, that the one I have. 38:35 So it, it was a, yes, a very good experience. [laughs] And is Nanashi Chan one of the personalities you met there? No, I just discovered their work afterwards. 38:48 But the singer of Nanashi Chan has a way of singing with a double voice, as Eastern Siberia shamans do. And the first puppet of the Fudzilogik that I did was, you know, indeed a shaman. 39:01 And I think it makes sense with this kind of objects w- which are in between living objects and just inanimate things, that to, to choose 39:14 this archetypal figure of the shaman, who plays the same role of being a passerby between the world and the other. This is the way Nanashi Chan sings, so I think it fits very much the idea of the project. 39:29 We will have the, the third, what we will show will be Shaman. It will be in, in August. Yeah. Before we have Bone Machine, and after the, The Petit Cloud. 39:41 And then as the last one in January next year, it's gonna be Yukitoko, the personality from the Japanese island. 39:53 This conversation is part of a series where we talk about museums, exhibitions, artists, and curators. See you in the next episode. I'm Ajita, and this is Conversation with Curators.